this years Trek movie..

[Thundershot]

I didn't realise this Star Trek film was so controversial amongst die hard Trek fans...

[Chopper]

Yup. Because there was sod all story really. That's the only reason. As I've said before as an action flick, 7 out of 10 as a Trek (thinking man's film) 5 out of 10. Its just proof that dumb action films are great sellers. Have you seen Idiocracy, Ed?

[Sundance]

the characers were largely good, but the story was total bollocks.

[Red Laser]

The book isn't bad.

[Ross SC]

best trek since search for spock. period.

[The Baron]

Loved it at the time of watching, but was unimpressed when I thought it through the day after.

I mean, what was Nero's motivation? How convenient was it that Kirk met old Spock? What the hell is red matter?

[Ross SC]

yeah, but next generation sucks....... why has picard got such a freakishly shaped head? thats why it's the best film since serach for spock.

[The Baron]

TNG is pretty dated now, but the Borg and Klingon episodes are superb!

[Red Laser]

Nero's motivation is Romulus had been destroyed by red matter so he went back into the past with the Narada to wipe out Vulcan and Earth to ensure Romulus future without a Federation. At least it's explained in the novel as this.

[Ross SC]

isnt it that obvious in the movie? well, revenge coz of the red matter & blaming the federation/spock anyway....