Minor Variation of Muton

Action Force, Red Shadows, SAS, Z Force, Q Force, Space Force... we love them all!
Post Reply
User avatar
rcm1234567
Private
Private
Posts: 48
Joined: 16 Feb 2008 14:34

Minor Variation of Muton

Post by rcm1234567 »

Minor Variation of Muton
I hope the following pictures & information will be of use.
There appears to be a minor variation of the Muton figure.
I’d noticed some years ago that some Action Force figures, including Muton, came with either very “thin” hands or “fat” hands.
At the time I thought it was more of a quality control problem than a proper variation. But it now seems there is a definite variation of Muton.
Muton #1A & #1B - Set.jpg
Pictured above are the two variations, the “thin” hand figure is the one on the Left (with close-up pictures on the top row) & the “fat” hand figure is the one on the right (with close-up pictures on the bottom row).

When someone posted pictures of the Red Shadow variations with “thin” & “thick” soles I checked mine & found that I had some with the “thin” soles & “thin” hands & some with the “thick” soles & “fat” hands.

I didn’t check out my other figures at the time but I’ve recently been sorting through my collection & noticed that I had six Muton figures but only one with the “fat” hands.
Looking closer I noticed the three white dots on the “neck plate” were painted a much brighter white on the “fat” hand figure.
(In the following pictures the “Thin” Hand Figure is always on the left & the “Fat” Hand Figure is always on the right.)
Muton #1A & #1B - Side by Side.jpg
At first I thought the paint might have been touched up but as I checked the paint on the “eye” I saw the small circular hole In the middle of the “eye” was slightly different.
On the five Mutons with the “thin” hands there is a slight slope to the edge of the hole.
On the one Muton with the “fat” hands there no slope, the face of the “eye” is completely flat.
Muton #1A & #1B - Isometric Detail.JPG
This is not easy to see as the painted lines on the “eye” continue down the slope so I’ve included a rough cutaway drawing below which shows what I mean better.
Muton cutaway drawing of eye.jpg
Packaging
I have two carded Mutons, one on an English/Italian card & one on a French/Dutch card. Both of these have the “Fat” hand figure with the Bright White Dots & the flat “eye” without the slope.

To summarise I think:
The Muton with “Thin” Hands was released first & had Faint White painted Dots on the Neck Plate and a Sloping edge to the “Eye” hole
The Muton with “Fat” Hands was released later & had Bright White painted Dots on the Neck Plate & No Sloping edge to the “Eye” hole.

Comparison of “Thin” & “Fat” Hand Figures
Muton #1A & #1B - Side by Side.jpg
Comparison of “Thin” & “Fat” Hands
Muton #1A & #1B - Thin & Fat Hands Comparison.jpg
Muton #1A & #1B - Thin & Fat Hands Comparison.jpg (17.42 KiB) Viewed 4430 times
Close up of “Thin” Hand Figure
Muton #1A.jpg
Close up of “Fat” Hand Figure
Muton #1B.jpg
This appears to be one of several figures with small but definite variations, a few of these are;

The Thin & Thick Sole Red Shadow figures.

The Kraken figures with different length Lines painted on the Torso (see my Post I suppose everyone knows this but...).

The Baron Ironblood figures with painted & unpainted hands.

The Space Patrollers & Space Security Troopers with & without painted Pouches etc.

The SAS Commando variations.

The Z Force Minesweeper with different legs.

It seems to me that there are at least three possibilities as to why there are these variations:

1) At some point many (if not all) of the figures were deliberately modified.

2) For some reason the moulds & paint masks were replaced.

3) Foreign releases were made from different moulds etc to the British releases.

If anyone knows why there are these variations please let us all know.

Robert (the infamous) rcm1234567

User avatar
Sundance
Friendly Dragonfly Inbound
Friendly Dragonfly Inbound
Posts: 5037
Joined: 20 Jan 2009 11:14

Re: Minor Variation of Muton

Post by Sundance »

the 'slope' you refer to is technically known as a bevel i believe...

Monkfish
Space Force
Space Force
Posts: 346
Joined: 25 Mar 2009 01:11
Location: Newfoundland, Canada

Re: Minor Variation of Muton

Post by Monkfish »

Good spot and really clear photos and explanations.

Quoted possibility: "3) Foreign releases were made from different moulds etc to the British releases."

Did :AFLogo: get produced anywhere other than Coalville?

If so then copies of the molds and slightly different compounds might have been used which would explain the slight fattening of the body parts. The non-bevelled facepiece could also be the result of taking the opportunity to simplify a part while the new molds were being made. Complete guesswork on my part, and I'm intrigued enough to want to know what warranted such small changes.

User avatar
paulitoy
he who dares...
he who dares...
Posts: 1798
Joined: 12 Nov 2007 22:09

Re: Minor Variation of Muton

Post by paulitoy »

-

Robert, this is an awesome, fantastic, wonderful post! Love it!

Now, if you have a spare few months, a detailed post like this for the whole range would be particularly excellent!

Great work Sir!

:doc: :doc: :doc:
Muchos Regardos,

Hoxworth Whipple


Image Image Image Image Image

User avatar
Squad Leader
The Eagle Has Landed
The Eagle Has Landed
Posts: 1412
Joined: 22 Feb 2009 21:00
Location: Buckinghamshire
Contact:

Re: Minor Variation of Muton

Post by Squad Leader »

excellent post mate! i didn't think AF had many variants but they keep appearing and im loving it, im still trying to get all the star wars variants and with more of the Action Force variants poping up its certainly gonna keep me busy for some time to come ;-)

:eagle2:

User avatar
SteveD
Assassin
Assassin
Posts: 6138
Joined: 22 May 2008 12:00
Location: In exile.

Re: Minor Variation of Muton

Post by SteveD »

I concur!!! Excellent comparison. This is clearly from the later releases like the dufus shads and the shiny black major. Are his limbs a bit less rubbery than the early one?
I'm off to inspect my mutons now!!!
Alte Volat

"BFTB Elite??? Moi??? Ooooooo, Missus - Titter ye not!"

User avatar
Hopper
Cobra
Cobra
Posts: 875
Joined: 09 Aug 2009 11:05

Re: Minor Variation of Muton

Post by Hopper »

Great work
I suspected there might me a variant Muton, but here is confirmation.

I shall add this to the great and ongoing Variant Project:
http://www.bloodforthebaron.com/links/A ... 0v.2.0.doc

Anything else?
"Not gods - Englishmen. The next best thing."
Brother Peachy Carnehan.

Post Reply

Return to “Action Force [Palitoy]”