Page 5 of 5
Re: Clone Wars Season 2 trailer
Posted: 28 Jul 2009 21:13
by Sundance
that's easy:
Battle Action Force is in a seprate universe to Marvel Action Force which is an alternate timeline of GI Joe.
Seemples. *chirp*
Re: Clone Wars Season 2 trailer
Posted: 28 Jul 2009 21:21
by The Baron
And wrong.
Re: Clone Wars Season 2 trailer
Posted: 28 Jul 2009 21:27
by Red Laser
It's all Star Wars as far as I'm concerned.
Re: Clone Wars Season 2 trailer
Posted: 28 Jul 2009 22:02
by Sundance
The Baron wrote:And wrong.
why?
Re: Clone Wars Season 2 trailer
Posted: 28 Jul 2009 23:15
by The Baron
Marvel Action Force is not an alternate timeline to Marvel GI Joe. They were written to coinicde.
Re: Clone Wars Season 2 trailer
Posted: 28 Jul 2009 23:43
by DAMartin
Yes, but not as smoothly as the TF UK stuff or the SW EU (wow, I'm good with acronyms!). Marvel Action Force changed the order of some Marvel US stories (like Silent Interlude UK version happening after everyone knows

already, while the US version was his 1st appearance), therefore being an alternate continuity.
Re: Clone Wars Season 2 trailer
Posted: 29 Jul 2009 01:53
by Chopper
Well Bill, I understand what you are saying, but the re-edits I've refereed to are a bit different. The Trailer the Baron posted of "Revisited" is just the tip of the iceberg. Big improvements are the Battle of Yavin - More ties and lot more intense. Also the moon and planet pan in the background, its absolutely incredible. Alderaan - Death Star orbits the planet and there are heaps of ties/destroyers coming and going. The Falcon Escape - more ties to add to the tension. Stuff like that. Not a rewrite as such.
The Phantom edits are tho, but the most interesting bit is the commentary and they are just fun to watch. I don't watch the edits a lot, but revisited gets watched more than the GL versions, its just jaw dropping. TBH as much as people criticise GL, look at what he's done. Speaks for itself really.
As far as Canon is concerned, I've not read much of the SWverse but so far all the cartoons and CG fit into the verse OK from a film point of view. GL has said the only bit of Canon in the Holiday Special is the cartoon were Boba Fett appears. The rest is supposed to be in the bin as far as he's concerned. I also have Ewoks, the Ewok Adventures, Droids, THS, this should give you some idea...
Mark